«上一篇/Previous Article|本期目录/Table of Contents|下一篇/Next Article»

《地震研究》[ISSN:1000-0666/CN:53-1062/P]

卷:

47

期数:

2024年04期

页码:

563-578

栏目:

出版日期:

2024-12-01

文章信息/Info

Title:

Analysis of the Aseismic Defects in Multi-Storey Buildings

作者:

阿拉塔¹; 郭迅²; 董孝曜³; 董策⁴; 罗若帆⁵; 王波²

(1.云南省地震局,云南 昆明 650224; 2.防灾科技学院,河北 三河 065201; 3.中国地震局工程力学研究所,黑龙江 哈尔滨 150080; 4.中国地震局地球物理研究所,北京 100081; 5.嘉应学院 土木工程学院,广东 梅州 514015)

Author(s):

A Lata¹; GUO Xun²; DONG Xiaoyao³; DONG Ce⁴; LUO Ruofan⁵; WANG Bo²

(1.Yunnan Earthquake Agency,Kunming 650024,Yunnan,China)(2.Institute of Disaster Prevention,Sanhe 065201,Hebei,China)(3.Institute of Engineering Mechanics,China Earthquake Administration,Harbin 150080,Heilongjiang,China)(4.Institute of Geophysics,China Earthquake Administration,Beijing 100081,China)(5.School of Civil Engineering,Jiaying University,Meizhou 514015,Guangdong,China)

关键词:

震害调查;  倒塌机理;  硬脆构件;  弱延构件;  变形饱和;  倒塌触发点

Keywords:

earthquake damage investigation;  collapse mechanism;  hard brittle component;  weakly extended component;  deformation saturation;  collapse trigger point

分类号:

TU973+.31

DOI:

10.20015/j.cnki.ISSN1000-0666.2024.0053

摘要:

我国强震多发、震灾严重,小震致灾、大震巨灾的状况时有发生,而多层建筑倒塌则是造成人员伤亡的主要因素。针对这些问题,基于2008年汶川8.0级地震以来川滇地区发生的十余次6.0级以上地震震害调查资料,对比了“破坏”与“未破坏”建筑的结构形式、建筑平立面布置、抗侧力构件分布及结构体系,剖析了建筑结构震害特点,总结了房屋破坏、倒塌的原因。认为在强地震中,建筑结构发生破坏及倒塌是因为其自身存在“散”“脆”“偏”“单”等抗震缺陷,其中“偏”的缺陷更为普遍。通过试验研究发现,墙体的约束使结构同层各抗侧力构件的力学性能相差巨大,即硬脆构件和弱延构件同层并存,这有别于传统抗震设计理论将同层所有构件同等对待的情况。

Abstract:

Earthquakes frequently occur in China; minor earthquakes may cause disasters and major earthquakes may cause catastrophes.And the collapse of multi-storey buildings is a major factor causing the loss of life.Aiming at these problems,and based on the earthquake damage data from the field investigation of a dozen of devastate earthquakes(M≥6.0)that have occurred in Sichuan and Yunnan since the 2008 Wenchuan M_S8.0 earthquake,this paper firstly compares the structural forms,plan and facade arrangement of buildings,distribution of lateral components,and structural system of the “damaged” and the “undamaged” buildings,then analyzes the seismic damage characteristics of the structures,and finally summarizes the causes of the buildings’ damage and collapse.It is believed that in the strong-earthquake event,the damage and collapse of the buildings are due to their own aseismic defects such as “dispersion”,“brittleness”,“eccentricity”,“singleness”.Among these defects,“eccentricity” in buildings is more common.Through the experimental research,it is found that the constraint of walls makes the mechanical properties of the lateral components of the same level of a building vary greatly,that is,the hard and brittle components and the weakly-extended components coexist on the same floor of a building.This is different from the traditional seismic design theory,which equally treats all components on the same floor of buildings.Finally,this paper analyzes the “eccentricity” defect of the damaged buildings in these over ten earthquake disasters,and proposes the Deformation Saturation theory that can more reasonably explain the damage and collapse of the buildings in earthquake disaster areas.

参考文献/References:

薄景山,李孝波,段玉石,等.2018.九寨沟7.0级地震学校建筑震害调查与分析[J].地震工程与工程振动,38(5):120-128.
Bo J S,Li X B,Duan Y S,et al.2018.Investigation and analysis of seismic damage to school buildings in M_S7.0 Jiuzhaigou earthquake[J].Earthquake Engineering and Engineering Dynamics,38(5):120-128.(in Chinese)
曹家乐,马恺泽,刘房添.2022.超高性能混凝土框架-核心筒抗震性能研究[J].华南地震,42(1):104-112.
Cao J L,Ma K Z,Liu F T.2022.Study on seismic behavior of ultra-high prformance concrete frame-core tube[J].South China Journal of Seismology,42(1):104-112.(in Chinese)
范晓庆,郭迅,王涛.2019.地震作用下钢筋混凝土柱的力学行为[D].三河:防灾科技学院.
Fan X Q,Guo X,Wang T.2019.Performance of reinforced concrete columns subjected to earthquake[D].Sanhe:Institute of Disaster Prevention.(in Chinese)
公茂盛,杨永强,谢礼立.2013.芦山7.0级地震中钢筋混凝土框架结构震害分析[J].地震工程与工程振动,33(3):20-26.
Gong M S,Yang Y Q,Xie L L.2013.Seismic damage to reinforced concrete frame buildings in Lushan M7.0 earthquake[J].Earthquake Engineering and Engineering Dynamics,33(3):20-26.(in Chinese)
顾祥林,付武荣,汪小林,等.2015.混凝土材料与结构破坏过程模拟分析[J].工程力学,32(11):9-17.
Gu X L,Fu W R,Wang X L,et al.2015.Numerical investigation on damage processes of concrete materials and structures[J].Engineering Mechanics,32(11):9-17.(in Chinese)
顾祥林,黄庆华,汪小林,等.2012.地震中钢筋混凝土框架结构倒塌反应的试验研究与数值仿真[J].土木工程学报,45(9):36-45.
Gu X L,Huang Q H,Wang X L,et al.2012.Spatial collapse responses of reinforced concrete frame structures under earthquakes test study and numerical simulation[J].China Civil Engineering Journal,45(9):36-45.(in Chinese)
郭富强.2023.基于极限承载力模型的民居建筑钢结构框架抗震性能试验分析[J].华南地震,43(2):158-164.
Guo F Q.2023.Experimental analysis of seismic performance of steel frame of residential buildings based on ultimate bearing capacity model[J].South China journal of seismology,43(2):158-164.(in Chinese)
郭迅.2018.钢筋混凝土框架结构地震倒塌机理[M].北京:中国建筑工业出版社,1-4.
Guo X.2018.Seismic collapse mechanism of reinforced concrete frame structure[M].Beijing:China Architecture & Building Press:1-4.(in Chinese)
郭迅.2019.从长宁地震反思韧性城乡建设[J].防灾科技学院学报,21(3):1-6.
Guo X.2019.Profound consideration on resilient urban and rural construction from the Changning earthquake[J].Journal of Institute of Disaster Prevention,21(3):1-6.(in Chinese)
郭迅.2022.变形饱和倒塌机理在泸定震害分析中的应用[J].防灾科技学院学报,24(4):1-10.
Guo X.2022.Application of deformation saturation theory in the seismic damage analysis of Luding M_S6.8 earthquake[J].Journal of Institute of Disaster Prevention,24(4):1-10.(in Chinese)
郭子雄,黄群贤,魏荣丰,等.2010.填充墙不规则布置对RC框架抗震性能影响试验研究[J].土木工程学报,43(11):46-54.
Guo Z X,Huang Q X,Wei R F,et al.2010.Experimental study of the seismic behavior of irregularly brick infilled RC frames[J].China Civil Engineering Journal,43(11):46-54.(in Chinese)
黄思凝,郭迅,孙得璋,等.2016.外廊式RC框架破坏机理的振动台试验研究[J].工程力学,33(12):63-71.
Huang S N,Guo X,Sun D Z,et al.2016.Shaking table test on failure mechanism RC frame with exterior corridor[J].Engineering Mechanics,33(12):63-71.(in Chinese)
蒋欢军,毛俊杰,刘小娟.2014.不同连接方式砌体填充墙钢筋混凝土框架抗震性能试验研究[J].建筑结构学报,35(3):60-67.
Jiang H J,Mao J J,Liu X J.2014.Experimental study on seismic performance of masonry infilled RC frame with different types of connections[J].Journal of Building Structures,35(3):60-67.(in Chinese)
雷雅婷,沈占锋,许泽宇,等.2022.基于D-LinkNet的2014年云南鲁甸M_S6.5地震建筑物损毁与重建评估[J].地震研究,45(4):608-615.
Lei Y T,Shen Zh F,Xu Z Y,et al.2022.Evaluation of the damaged buildings in the 2014 Ludian M_S6.5 Earthquake in Yunnan and their post-earthquake reconstruction based on D-LinkNet[J].Journal of Seismological Research,45(4):608-615.(in Chinese)
李碧雄,雷涛,邓建辉,等.2009.汶川地震中学建筑震害研究[J].四川大学学报(工程科学版),41(3):172-179,215.
Li B X,Lei T,Deng J H,et al.2009.Lessons learnt from performance of school buildings in Wenchuan earthquake region[J].Sichuan University Journal(Engineering Science Edition),41(3):172-179,215.(in Chinese)
李碧雄.2015.地震中砌体填充墙和RC框架梁柱协同作用机理[J].建筑结构,45(4):96-106.
Li B X.2015.Interaction mechanism between masonry infilled wall and bounding RC frame under earthquake[J].Building Structure,45(4):96-106.(in Chinese)
李昆,周煜,陶思宇,等.2021.云南漾濞6.4级地震公共建筑的震害特征[J].世界地震工程,37(3):1-8.
Li K,Zhou Y,Tao S Y,et al.2021.Seismic damage to public buildings in the M6.4 Yangbi earthquake in Yunnan[J].World Earthquake Engineering,37(3):1-8.(in Chinese)
卢存恕,常伏德,吴福英,等.1999.建筑抗震设计实例[M].北京:中国建筑工业出版社:13-16.
Lu C S,Chang F D,Wu F Y,et al.1999.Examples of seismic design of buildings[M].Beijing: China Architecture & Building Press:13-16.(in Chinese)
罗若帆,金显廷,郭迅,等.2022.泸定6.8级地震结构震害调查与分析[J].防灾科技学院学报,24(4):46-55.
Luo R F,Jin X T,Guo X,et al.2022.Investigation and analysis of structure damage in the Sichuan Luding M_S6.8 earthquake in[J].Journal of Institute of Disaster Prevention,24(4):46-55.(in Chinese)
清华大学土木结构组,西南交通大学土木结构组,北京交通大学土木结构组.2008.汶川地震建筑震害分析[J].建筑结构学报,29(4):1-9.
Civil structure team from Tsing Hua University,Civil structure team from Southwest Jiaotong University,Civil structure team from Beijing Jiaotong University.2008.Earthquake damage analysis of Wenchuan earthquake[J].Journal of Building Structures,29(4):1-9.(in Chinese)
谭皓,李杰,张电吉,等.2011.玉树地震框架结构建筑震害调查[J].工程抗震与加固改造,33(5):133-139
Tan H,Li J,Zhang D J,et al.2011.An investigation on frame structure damaged in Yushu earthquake[J].Earthquake Resistant Engineering and Retrofiffing,33(5):133-139.(in Chinese)
王波.2020.基于震害的结构倒塌机理研究[D].北京:中国地震局地球物理研究所.
Wang B.2020.Research on collapse mechanism of structures based on earthquake damage[D].Beijing:Institute of Geophysics,China Earthquake Administration.(in Chinese)
王多智,孙柏涛,戴君武,等.2018.底部框架砖房地震倒塌调查与分析[J].哈尔滨工业大学学报,50(2):184-190.
Wang D Z,Sun B T,Dai J W,et al.2018.Collapse investigation and analysis of RC frame supported masonry structures under the earthquake[J].Journal of Harbin Institute of Technology,50(2):184-190.(in Chinese)
温增平,徐超,陆鸣,等.2009.汶川地震重灾区典型钢筋混凝土框架结构震害现象[J].北京工业大学学报,35(6):753-760.
Wen Z P,Xu C,Lu M,et al.2009.Damage features of RC frame structures in Wenchuan earthquake[J].Journal of Beijing University of Technology,35(6):753-760.(in Chinese)
谢贤鑫,潘毅,寇创琦,等.2022.泸定6.8级地震学校建筑典型震害调查与分析[J].地震工程与工程振动,42(6):12-24.
Xie X X,Pan Y,Kou C Q,et al.2022.Typical seismic damage investigation and analysis to school buildings in the Luding M_S6.8 earthquake[J].Earthquake Engineering and Engineering Dynamics,42(6):12-24.(in Chinese)
闫培雷,孙柏涛,张昊宇.2014.芦山7.0级强烈地震钢筋混凝土框架结构教学楼震害[J].土木工程学报,47(S1):24-28.
Yan P L,Sun B T,Zhang H Y.2014.Seismic damage to RC frame teaching buildings in Lushan M_S7.0 earthquake[J].China Civil Engineering Journal,47(S1):24-28.(in Chinese)
杨永强,公茂盛,谢礼立,等.2014.芦山M7.0级地震中砖混结构民居震害特征分析[J].建筑结构,44(18):68-70.
Yang Y Q,Gong M S,Xie L L,et al.2014.Analysis on seismic damage characteristics of masonry-concrete structure dwellings in Lushan M7.0 earthquake[J].Building Structure,44(18):68-70.(in Chinese)
叶列平,曲哲,陆新征,等.2008.提高建筑结构抗地震倒塌能力的设计思想与方法[J].建筑结构学报,29(1):41-50.
Ye L P,Qu Z,Lu X Z,et al.2008.Collapse prevention of building structures a lesson from the Wenchuan earthquake[J].Journal of Building Structures,29(1):41-50.(in Chinese)
岳茂光,王东升,孙志国,等.2012.汶川地震下框架结构的抗倒塌能力分析[J].工程力学,29(11):250-256.
Yue M G,Wang D S,Sun Z G,et al.2012.Analysis on collapse resistant capability of reinforced concrete frame structure under Wenchuan earthquake[J].Engineering Mechanics,29(11):250-256.(in Chinese)
张炳晖,杨玉红,赵亚涛,等.2019.柱端箍筋不同加密的钢筋混凝土柱的抗震性能分析[J].混凝土与水泥制品,(11):70-73.
Zhang B H,Yang Y H,Zhao Y T,et al.2019.Analysis of seismic performance of reinforced concrete columns with different encryption stirrups at column ends[J].China Concrete and Cement Products,(11):70-73.(in Chinese)
张浩.2019.柱端弯矩增大系数对RC框架结构抗震性能影响[D].哈尔滨:中国地震局工程力学研究所.
Zhang H.2019.Effect of column end moment increase coefficient on seismic performance of RC frame structure[D].Harbin:Institute of Engineering Mechanics,China Earthquake Administration.(in Chinese)
张令心,朱柏洁,陶正如,等.2019.九寨沟7.0级地震房屋震害现场调查及其破坏特征[J].地震工程学报,41(4):1053-1059.
Zhang L X,Zhu B J,Tao Z R,et al.2019.Filed investigation and failure characteristics of buildings damage by the 7.0 magnitude earthquake in Jiuzhaigou[J].China Earthquake Engineering Journal,41(4):1053-1059.(in Chinese)
赵仕兴,杨姝姮,唐元旭,等.2023.四川泸定6.8级地震震中区域建筑震害考察与思考[J].建筑结构,53(7):1-8.
Zhao S X,Yang S H,Tang Y X,et al.2023.Investigation and consideration of building damage in the epicenter of Sichuan Luding M6.8 earthquake[J].Building Structure,53(7):1-8.(in Chinese)
GB 50011—2010.建筑抗震设计规范[S].
GB 50011—2010.Code for seismic design of buildings[S].(in Chinese)
A L T,Guo X,Luo R F,et al.2022.Experimental study on the seismic performance of RC frames considering the cast sequence of infilled walls and columns[J].Structures,(44):186-199.
Baghi H,Oliveira A,Valen?a J,et al.2018.Behavior of reinforced concrete frame with masonry infill wall subjected to vertical load[J].Engineering Structures,171:476-487.
Bal I^· E,Smyrou E.2016.Simulation of the earthquake-induced collapse of a school building in Turkey in 2011 Van Earthquake[J].Bulletin of Earthquake Engineering,14(12):3509-3528.
Barbosa A R,Fahnestock L A,Fick D R,et al.2017.Performance of medium-to-high rise reinforced concrete frame buildings with masonry infill in the 2015 Gorkha,Nepal,Earthquake[J].Earthquake Spectra,33(S1):197-218.
Dizhur D,Ingham J,Griffith M,et al.2016.Performance of unreinforced masonry and infilled RC buildings during the 2015 Gorkha,Nepal earthquake sequence[C].16th International Brick and Block Masonry Conference.
Günay M S,Mosalam K M.2010.Structural engineering reconnaissance of the April 6,2009,Abruzzo,Italy,earthquake,and lessons learned,PEER Report 2010-105[R].Pacific Earthquake Engineering Research Center,University of California,Berkeley,CA.
Moya L,Yamazaki F,Liu W,et al.2018.Detection of collapsed buildings from lidar data due to the 2016 Kumamoto earthquake in Japan[J].Natural Hazards and Earth System Sciences,18(1):65-78.
Park R.1999.Capacity design of ductile RC building structures for earthquake resistance[J].ACI Structural Engineering,70(16):279-289.
Paulay T,Priestley M J N.1992.Seismic Design of Reinforced Concrete and Masonry Buildings[M].New York:Wiley Interscience.
Paulay T.1981.Developments in the seismic design of reinforced concrete frames in New Zealand[J].Canadian Journal of Civil Engineering,8(2):91-113.
Teguh M.2017.Experimental evaluation of masonry infill walls of RC frame buildings subjected to cyclic loads[J].Procedia Engineering,171:191-200.
Varum H,Furtado A,Rodrigues H,et al.2017.Seismic performance of the infill masonry walls and ambient vibration tests after the Ghorka 2015,Nepal earthquake[J].Bulletin of Earthquake Engineering,15(3):1185-1212.
Yépez F,Yépez O.2016.Role of construction materials in the collapse of RC buildings after M_W7.8 Pedernales-Ecuador earthquake,April 2016[J].Case Studies in Structural Engineering,39(7):24-31.

备注/Memo

备注/Memo:

收稿日期:2024-01-16.
基金项目:云南省地震科技创新团队(CXTD202401); 国家自然科学基金面上项目(52278489); 河北省高等学校科学研究项目(BJK2022066).
第一作者简介:阿拉塔(1978-),高级工程师,博士,主要从事建筑结构抗震研究.E-mail:alata182@126.com.

常用功能

更新日期/Last Update: 2024-08-20